AmericasContainersDry CargoGasOperationsPorts and LogisticsTankers

Baltimore bridge investigation targets ship’s electrical failure

Investigators in Baltimore are focusing on the Dali’s electrical power system and its circuit breakers and have called in the ship’s builder, Hyundai Heavy Industries from South Korea, with a preliminary report on this year’s most high-profile shipping accident set to be released in the first week of May. 

Jennifer Homendy, chair of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), gave members of Congress in Washington DC an update yesterday into the ongoing investigation into the Dali’s allision with the Francis Scott Key Bridge last month.

“We have had the manufacturer of equipment in the engine room to look closely at the electrical power system. We’re continuing to look at that. We’ve asked for additional assistance from the manufacturer who returned from overseas this week with experts to look at the circuit breakers,” Homendy said. 

The Dali, managed by Synergy and on charter to Maersk, has been pinned down under mangled steel in the Patapsco River since it slammed into the bridge on March 26, killing six road maintenance workers. Video of the ship in the minutes prior to hitting the bridge shows the ship losing power repeatedly.

The NTSB recovered the Dali’s voyager data recorder last month, which showed power failed for just one minute and three seconds as it approached Baltimore’s largest bridge, and that the lead pilot tried to swing the 300 m long vessel clear of a collision by dropping its port anchor to pivot it away.

The disabled ship ran into a support pillar and caused much of the bridge to tumble into the Patapsco River at roughly 1:30 am on March 26. Just moments before, at 1:26 am, the pilot of the ship called for tugboat assistance, according to the voyage data recorder. At 1:27 am, the pilot made an order to drop the ship anchor.

The US Coast Guard confirmed last month that the containership’s engines had undergone routine maintenance during its port stay while a Baltimore port worker told CNN that the Dali had “serious power outages” in the days before it lost propulsion 

Julie Mitchell, co-administrator of Container Royalty, which tracks the tonnage on containerships coming in and out of Baltimore, told CNN the ship was suffering from power outages for two days prior to its departure. 

“They had a severe electrical problem. It was total power failure, loss of engine power, everything,” Mitchell said, citing a number of reefers onboard that had been tripping circuit breakers.

“The vessel went dead, no steering power and no electronics,” said an officer aboard the ship in comments reported by the Wall Street Journal last month. “One of the engines coughed and then stopped. The smell of burned fuel was everywhere in the engine room and it was pitch black.” 

Wes Moore, the governor of Maryland, said yesterday 34 containers have been moved from the bow of the Dali out of more than 4,700 containers on the ship. He said the goal is to remove 178 of them in order to refloat the Dali. 

“That work is complicated and that work is dangerous because just one empty container that’s sitting on the vessel can have a weight of more than one and a half tons,” the governor said. 

The US Navy on Wednesday released sonar images (see below) of the bridge beneath the surface.

The US Army Corp of Engineers has said some of the riverbed will need dredging in order to remove parts of the shattered bridge. 

Sam Chambers

Starting out with the Informa Group in 2000 in Hong Kong, Sam Chambers became editor of Maritime Asia magazine as well as East Asia Editor for the world’s oldest newspaper, Lloyd’s List. In 2005 he pursued a freelance career and wrote for a variety of titles including taking on the role of Asia Editor at Seatrade magazine and China correspondent for Supply Chain Asia. His work has also appeared in The Economist, The New York Times, The Sunday Times and The International Herald Tribune.

Comments

  1. QUOTE: Julie Mitchell, co-administrator of Container Royalty, which tracks the tonnage on containerships coming in and out of Baltimore, told CNN the ship was suffering from power outages for two days prior to its departure. END QUOTE .
    That is what this “all knowing Lady ” heard. And it is then hearsay and/or rumor.
    Besides:
    The lack of any other reports is “the dog that didn’t bark”.

    What the ” I know it all ” Lady says further is also interesting:
    QUOTE:
    “They had a severe electrical problem. It was total power failure, loss of engine power, everything,” Mitchell said, citing a number of reefers onboard that had been tripping circuit breakers.
    END QUOTE

    I am not sure but all vessels alongside have usually their engines shut down , unless the vessel is fitted with CPP and Owners have tons of money and are crazy enough to keep the M/E running.

    Looks the “all knowing ” Lady never heard and/or experienced , that faulty reefers upon hook up can be a big headache for both ship’s and shore side electricians . Surely She must grab a nail and stick it into life socket to understand this, as it seems too complicated for her phenomenon.
    Empirical discovery can be very enlightening.

    In conclusion , combined with my long time hands on experience with US longshoremen , regret to observe it smells to me, like another attempt and example of Sal Alinsky type of shake downs.|

    1. Yeah, she’s definitely trying to be famous. Obviously, Madam has no clue whatsoever.

    2. In US usually friendly people in port (pilots, stevedores etc.) immediately inform USCG in case of any technical issues onboard of foreign vessel. If this ship was suffering from power outage for two days, the local USCG commander should know that. Why didn’t he take any actions? Normally, USCG visit vessel and call class surveyor for investigation of failure (so they are barely understand anything in modern onboard machinery).

      1. EXACTLY!!
        In the environment You have just described a crew member on foreign flagged vsl can not cough ( although fart would be more appropriate – appologies for unparlamentary wording) ), without local rats and snitches springing to action and fulfiling their call of patriotic duty. 😉

        Creating extra hype regarding any accident there ,is their favourite pass time and speciality. Removing safety pins from hold access trunks, braking illumination bulbs there, littering decs with all sorts of garbage including banana skins is just a small sample of their bag of lousy , dirty trics designed to milk Owners via medical compensation payments/claims .

        You go there , then You must be wired better then agent 007 , have cameras everywhere and even better the drones in order to defend their claims, as in persuing their missions, they are also a compulsive & pathological liars .

        There, is a super-mega hostile environment for foreign crews and vessels. I hope I will live to the moment they get there fully automated ghost terminals as handlig ghost is a walk in the park in comparison with US stevedores. It is my subjective opinion based on a freght train of experience there.

  2. The Lady is probably a cargo monitor. Modern reefers have modems so the clients can monitor their cargo.
    As a former ships Captain, I can tell you that when she talks about the containers tripping out it means there was a “blackout” as we called it, on the ship. Ie – total loss of power. So if this was happening regularly in the port before departure, the ship knew about their power issues. This is a Synergy managed vessel which probably has a full Indian crew. Good luck to the USCG getting a straight answer.

  3. I am not a ships captain, I am not a ships mechanic or electrician. I am familiar with boats on the river. In my personal experience if I drop anchor off the port, I turn left automatically,,, before anyone yells at me I understand the size, weight and speed of the ship took a longer reaction time,,, but from what I saw in the videos the ship turned RIGHT and headed straight to that support! I never saw even a drift left from the anchor, but no one what’s to explain that

    1. Dear Madam.
      You are the Captain.
      Try the folowing experiment. Find a boat which has LOA/B ratio similar to M/V Dali abt 300/48 . Then bring this boat to stb swing . Once the ROT( rate of turn ) is high cut your engine , put your rudder to zero or leave it where it was and let go your port anchor and observe if your stb swing is halted or not or …….may be the stb swing is accelerated ?? . Share your observations with others.

      Before doing this i will strongly recommend to read something about “pivot point” in relation to ship/boat handling. But if you are interested in the explanation , hypothesis , theories , views abt M/V Dali EVEN ffrom old salts , then go to gCaptain Forum and read all topics/threads on Dali. Enjoy.

Back to top button